Mullvad vs Proton VPN (2026): Which Is Actually More Private?

Mullvad vs Proton VPN at a glance

Company background and jurisdiction

Mullvad is based in Sweden and has built its entire brand around minimal data collection since 2009. Proton VPN is operated by Proton, a Swiss company known first for its encrypted email service and now for a full privacy suite that includes Proton Mail, Proton Pass, Proton Drive, and Proton Calendar. Both Sweden and Switzerland have historically been viewed as reasonably favorable jurisdictions for privacy-focused services, though neither country is part of the Five Eyes intelligence-sharing alliance's core membership, which is a point in favor of both providers.

Where the two diverge is company philosophy. Mullvad has stayed narrowly focused on the VPN product itself, while Proton has expanded into a broader ecosystem. That expansion means Proton VPN benefits from shared infrastructure, brand trust, and resources across a larger organization, but it also means your subscription and account activity may be more closely tied to a wider Proton account footprint if you use multiple Proton products together.

Account sign-up and anonymity

This is where Mullvad's approach stands out. According to Mullvad's own pricing page, you generate an account by clicking a single button, which immediately produces an account number — no email, name, or personal details are requested at any point. Mullvad also explicitly supports paying with cash, along with Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash, Monero, bank wire, and conventional methods like credit card and PayPal. For cash payments, you mail an envelope with currency and a randomly generated payment token, which is about as close to an anonymous VPN subscription as you're likely to find.

Proton VPN, by contrast, requires an email address to create an account on both its free and paid tiers. You can use an alias or a secondary email rather than your primary one, and Proton does support privacy-respecting payment options in some regions, but the sign-up flow itself is not built around anonymity in the same way Mullvad's is. If minimizing any link between your identity and your VPN account is your top priority, this difference matters.

Logging policy and audits

Both providers publish no-logs claims. Proton VPN states directly on its pricing and features page that it keeps no session usage logs of what users do online and does not log metadata that could compromise privacy — this no-logs commitment is listed as a standard included feature across its free, Plus, and Unlimited tiers. Mullvad has long maintained a similar no-logs stance as a core part of its brand identity, reinforced by its refusal to require any personal information at sign-up in the first place, which limits what could be logged even if policies changed.

Both companies discuss their security practices and infrastructure choices in public materials, though we'd encourage readers to check each provider's current transparency reports and audit history directly, since these are updated periodically and specifics can change.

Server network and everyday usability

Proton VPN's paid tiers offer a considerably larger footprint than Mullvad. Proton's own pricing page cites a large server network for its Plus and Unlimited plans, though the exact server and country counts vary across different sections of that same page — ranging from roughly 2,000 servers in 10+ countries to over 20,000 servers in 140+ countries — so treat any specific figure as approximate. That scale generally translates into more location options for streaming, better odds of finding a fast server nearby, and broader P2P/BitTorrent support, which Proton also lists as included on paid tiers. Proton VPN additionally bundles NetShield, its ad, tracker, and malware blocker, on paid plans.

Mullvad's network is smaller and more curated by comparison. It doesn't publish the same country and server counts as Proton, and it does not support port forwarding, a limitation Mullvad addresses directly on its own site. For users who want a wider server selection or heavier streaming and torrenting flexibility, Proton VPN's infrastructure is generally the more capable option.

Pricing approach

Mullvad uses a single flat monthly rate no matter whether you pay monthly or top up a year at a time — there's no discount for committing longer term, and Mullvad states this rate has not changed since the service launched. The only built-in discount is a reduction for paying with supported cryptocurrencies, reflecting lower processing costs. Mullvad also offers a 14-day money-back guarantee, except for cash payments, due to anti-money-laundering rules.

Proton VPN follows a more conventional tiered model: a free plan with limited server choice and speed, a VPN Plus plan with full server access and higher speeds, and a Proton Unlimited bundle that adds the rest of the Proton suite. Proton advertises savings for longer commitments and backs paid plans with a 30-day money-back guarantee. Because exact rates and promotional discounts shift over time on both sites, we'd recommend checking each provider's official pricing page before subscribing rather than relying on any number you see elsewhere.

Which is actually more private?

On the narrow question of anonymity at the point of purchase, Mullvad has the edge: no email required, a numbered account system, and genuine cash payment support are hard to match. Proton VPN's no-logs commitment appears just as serious, but its sign-up process ties your subscription to an email address by default, which is a meaningfully different privacy posture even if Proton doesn't log your browsing activity.

If your threat model centers on leaving as little identifying information as possible with your VPN provider, Mullvad is the stronger choice. If you value a no-logs VPN backed by a larger company with a broader privacy product suite, faster speeds, and a bigger server list, Proton VPN is very likely the better everyday fit. Many privacy-conscious users we've seen in the community actually run both, treating them as complementary rather than mutually exclusive tools.

Frequently Asked Questions